What no one tells you about the “hidden job market”
If you’ve been job searching and feeling stuck, read this before you apply again
When people talk about job searching, there’s a familiar story that gets repeated.
You apply, you interview, you’re evaluated fairly and eventually something works out.
That version does exist. But sometimes, there’s another one.
I know this because I’ve seen it from the inside.
When the process suddenly speeds up
I remember a time when a hiring manager already knew a candidate. They spoke to my manager, exchanged a few thoughts and that alone was enough to shift the pace.
The process started to change. Steps disappeared. Timelines shortened. Parts of the interview loop that were usually described as “non-negotiable” quietly became optional.
The person was qualified, without question. Whether they were clearly the strongest candidate on paper was harder to say.
What seemed to matter most in that moment wasn’t a single interview score or comparison, but the fact that they were already known and therefore felt like a safer decision.
✦ ✧ ✦
The part people rarely admit
There’s something about hiring that’s uncomfortable to say out loud.
Sometimes, you’re not completely convinced by a candidate. They’re fine. They meet most of the requirements. Nothing is actively wrong. But you also wouldn’t normally rush to an offer.
Then, in the middle of that uncertainty, you hear something small. That they’ve worked with someone you trust, or that a colleague knows them well or that they come recommended by someone whose judgment you respect.
And gradually, the uncertainty starts to feel smaller.
Not because connections replace competence, but because they reduce risk. Hiring is expensive, stressful, and deeply human work. When trust enters the picture, doubt often softens.
From the outside, this can look unfair. From the inside, it usually looks like people trying to make the safest decision they can with limited information.
Those two perspectives can exist at the same time.
✦ ✧ ✦
When a role appears out of nowhere
I remember another moment when a manager casually mentioned a friend’s contact. They had just finished their master’s and were looking for a job. At the time, there was no open role, no hiring plan, no job posting anyone could point to.
A few conversations later, a role existed.
Not because the business had suddenly identified a critical gap, but because someone trusted someone else and thought, maybe we can make this work.
It wasn’t framed as unfair or intentional favouritism. No one said it out loud that way. And this isn’t how most roles are filled.
But it just…happens. Quietly, almost naturally, in the way many workplace decisions do.
There was no competitive process. No stack of CVs. No long discussion about interview feedback or team fit.
They didn’t win against hundreds of applicants. They never entered the race in the first place.
And once you’ve seen this happen a few times, it changes how you look at applying altogether.
✦ ✧ ✦
Why applying online can feel so discouraging
A lot of career advice still assumes a very linear system.
Put in effort, show merit, get results. But often, hiring doesn’t move in a straight line.
A role might be opened publicly, applications collected, interviews planned and at the same time, conversations are happening in parallel. Someone knows someone. A name comes up. A recommendation adds context.
The job posting is real. The process is real. But proximity, trust and timing can still shape how things move forward (especially in a tight or uncertain market!).
That tension between the formal process and the informal one is what people are usually referring to when they talk about the hidden job market.
It isn’t secret or illegal. It’s just informal, human and rarely explained out loud.
How I started thinking differently about networking
For a long time, I thought networking meant asking for favours. That framing made me uncomfortable, so I avoided it. I told myself the process had to be fair in a very strict sense and that reaching out meant I hadn’t earned it.
What changed my mind was being on both sides.
I’ve been the person who needed help, sometimes just a conversation, a referral or a bit of guidance. Even when it didn’t lead to an offer, it still mattered. It made the process feel less isolating.
And I’ve been on the other side too, happy to help someone who reached out, simply because I remembered how heavy job searching can feel.
Seeing hiring from the inside made the rest click. So much of it happens through conversations that never make it into a job posting.
That’s when my definition of networking shifted.
You can message people. Even if it feels awkward. Even if most messages go unanswered.
You don’t need a perfect pitch. And the worst-case scenario is being ignored, which, honestly?!, is easier to recover from than a long interview process leading nowhere.
At least here, there’s upside, a real chance of finding something new.
✦ ✧ ✦
Big sister note
If any of this made you uncomfortable, that makes sense.
Most of us were taught that if we worked hard, kept our heads down and followed the process, things would eventually work out. For a long time, that belief felt safer than questioning how things actually move behind the scenes.
Seeing hiring from the inside didn’t make me cynical. It made me more compassionate toward the system and toward myself.
Because when things don’t move, it’s not always a reflection of your effort, your talent or your worth.
Sometimes it’s timing. Sometimes it’s information you never had access to. Sometimes it’s simply that you weren’t in the room when a conversation happened.
That doesn’t mean you’ve done anything wrong. It just means the rules are more human and more uneven than we’re usually told.
So yes, send the message. Connect with someone by telling them what you genuinely admire about their role, the path they’ve taken or their company.
If you’d ever seen my cold-emails during a job search, you’d probably cringe. I do too. Honestly, most of them went nowhere.
But some didn’t. Some people replied. Some took the time to help. Some opened doors I didn’t even know existed. I’ll always be grateful for that.
That’s how things actually move. ✨
If this brought something up for you, you can reply directly to this email or message me on Substack and tell me what you’re thinking. I read every one. ✨
I’ve added a short poll below as well, just to get a sense of how familiar this topic was. 💌